Before the US Army's decision, the SIG Sauer P320 had to face a comprehensive selection process. The frame is the handgun for the FN 509, while the trigger group is the handgun for the Sig P320. This video compares the differences and similarities of the Sig Sauer M17 and the FN 509 Tactical. Sig Sauer. installed and worked fine in my wife's P320. Posted by 1 year ago. Why FN and not the Glock 19 or Sig P320? The P320 seems like an obvious choice, I am assuming that like the AR-15, soon the aftermarket will explode with accessories, having been adopted by the military. For a newer shooter will the high bore axis be a problem? This gun has lots of competitor on the market, but one that stands out in many gun buyers’ minds. How did they compare? I am partial to FN- own a Scar 17, 16, FNX Tac 45, FNS 9C and 509. Hot. I have both the Sig p320 and the FN 509, My Sig was definitely my favored gun until spending a few range days with the 509, now it seems to be a disappointment on accuracy and ease of use, but I’m a lefty and that could play into that feeling, The 509 is much easier to handle, load, release, fire than the 320, it shoot’s tight groups almost effortlessly at 25 yards and closer, zero malfunctions, just a pleasure to carry and … Not at all with the 509. Aftermarket, the 320 has an underwhelming apex trigger kit and … Compare the dimensions and specs of Sig Sauer P320 M18 and FN 509 MDR Compact The trigger take up and reset is better, the grips feel better and more aggressive, which I prefer. Which would you choose and why? I love the higher sights. ... help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts. The IWI Masada has external features similar to the FN 509 Tactical and the Glock 19X, while its configurable heart resembles the internals of the SIG P320. VS. Sig Sauer . Armed Citizens. The Masada was announced a couple of years ago, but it took the company until … The Army’s loss is our gain. Close. Thus the FN 509 Midsize was not born out of a vacuum, but is a pistol created for civilians after years of proving the FN name on battlefields and training grounds. When a variant of the SIG Sauer P320 was adopted by the U.S. Army over the Glock as the M17, it was the first win for SIG in the handgun market in a long time. Featured Products . FN 509 – $550; Glock 19 Gen 5 – $575; Smith & Wesson M&P 2.0 – $550; Sphinx SDP – $799; Now, that’s not to say that each doesn’t have awesome characteristics and, in no way shape or form, am I saying the Sig P320 is superior to these guns. The main thing that puts the 509 way out front for me is how easy it is to aim, acquire target and make follow up shots with. Sig Sauer: Community for Sig Enthusiasts r/ SigSauer. 28 comments. P320 XCompact. A large number of well-known competitors also took part. Question. SIG also released a civilian-variant model, which very much lives up to the hype. P320 Build. Join. What if the U.S. Army had selected FN America as the winner of the XM17 Modular Handgun System competition?Well, then we’d be seeing a slew of articles discussing the merits of the FN 509.. Compare the dimensions and specs of FN 509 Midsize and Sig Sauer P320 XCompact. 3. With that, from what they've told me I wouldn't bet on an MRDS cut any time soon. The 509 is built off of existing designs in the FNS9 and IIRC FN was touting 1 million rounds through one. I shot both recently and ended up buying the FN 509. Calibers: 9mm Luger . Apex triggers for Sig P320, one flat, one curved. I am itching for a new pew pew. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. By using our Services, you agree to our use of cookies.Learn More. Watch this: Hot New Top. FN 509 or SIG P320. So I inadvertatenly stumbled into this form factor. FN 509 vs Sig P320? P320 X-Carry. Compare the dimensions and specs of FN 509 and Sig Sauer P320 M18 But Sig Sauer and its undeniably awesome P320 emerged victorious, and FN decided to make the 509 available for commercial sale. Aftermarket wise, what exactly are you looking for? Question. Smith and Wesson. … Reliability wise, I've heard they are the same too. 223. ... FN 509 Midsize . The guns included the FN 509, Glock 17 Gen5, Heckler & Koch P30, Sig Sauer P320 Full-Size, Smith & Wesson M&P9 M2.0 and the 5-inch-barreled Walther PPQ M2. FN Build. Best 9mm Sidearm Pistol Contenders. I'm still going to try to get my hands on it and the 509 before I put down any money, but if the P320 fits my hand well, it's a pretty safe bet that's what I'll go with. I like the ergonomics and grip better on the FN 509 (Sig feels a tad fat in the hand but it’s perfectly fine). But, I put the 509 to an honest comparison before buying a midsize carry 9mm and it blew the Sig, Glock and Springfield away. I have been looking to get my first handgun, and for the most part have narrowed it down to between the 509 and P320. CZ Build. Capacity: 10 +1 (9mm Luger) 15 +1 (9mm Luger) Sig Sauer P320 X-Carry . Reminds me of the FNX Tactical 45 set up. My FN contact tells me they will be available soon. 9. We compare the FN 509 vs SIG P320 Carry, both chambered in 9mm. The FN is 2.5 oz lighter than the Sig, but that's not enough for me to consider it a deciding factor. I think what I'll end up doing is buying the P320 FDE 9mm compact and a full sized 357 Sig X change kit. Billet plug for those who want to plug/protect their front sight hole on their slide or 417 compensator $12.00. To learn more about the all-new FN 509 Compact MRD optics-ready pistol, visit fnamerica.com. Regarding the SIG P320, the U.S. Army recently chose a variation of it as its service pistol, designating it the M17; then every other military branch followed in suit. I like the ergonomics and grip better on the FN 509 (Sig feels a tad fat in the hand but it’s perfectly fine). Picked up a P320 AXG Scorpion and DeltaPoint pro today. If the 509 is very close in quality to the P320, it might be a tough choice. Looking at getting a new CCW and narrowed it down to these two (P320 vs 509). Featured Products . The 509 Midsize has a polymer frame and is similar in size to a Glock 19 or Sig Sauer P320, which means it is on the larger size of compact yet small enough to be comfortably concealed. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Posted by 3 years ago. Online Now. The 509, being so new, hasn't had a chance to really leave an impression on the market outside of early positive buzz, so I thought I would ask the question of anyone who would know - how does it compare to the P320? Handgun Search; Tabletop Compare; Contribute; Contact; FN . I'd wager they'll both run a similar amount of rounds before running into malfunctions. The triggers are very close, but the Sig has the edge and I would likely drop an Apex trigger in the Sig (didn’t care much for the effect I saw for the Apex in the 509). Sig P320 Compact vs Mid-size FN 509. The more I look at it, the more I want the P320. To entries into the militaries MHS Program. Basically, the FN 509 is a product-improved version of FN’s existing striker-fired, polymer duty gun, the FNS, which has seen some success in both law … Posted by 9 hours ago. FN 509 or SIG P320. ... FN 509 Midsize . I have always loved FN though, the FAL being my favorite traditional battle rifle, the SCAR 17 being my favorite modern one. Handgun Hero lets you visually compare any two handguns side-by-side. FN. Also, this is one of the only pistols that I do not have to compensate with. P365 Build. Right off the bat, all six test guns have polymer frames and steel slides. Stumbled upon your post on a Google search. The FN and Sig are very close in size. Has anyone shot both? The U.S. Army chooses based upon what the U.S. Army thinks is important. Which do you feel is the better combat pistol? Thanks for helping me out. 118 Single Port Compensator. 509 Midsize. As for the modularity of the FN 509, look at the design of the FN 509, then look at the design of the Sig P320. Compare old pistols vs new pistols, pocket revolvers vs subcompacts, or anything else. save. The results are very close, but only one can win. Usually I have to correct my low-to-the-left placement. EDIT: It seems the actual purchase price of a P320 Compact nowadays is well under $600, so that certainly makes it an easier choice I suppose. Idiosyncrasies. Created Jul 22, 2010. You may not be ready to carry a red dot just yet, but the future is coming. Glock Build. Striker-Fired Compact Pistol . I have been looking to get my first handgun, and for the most part have narrowed it down to between the 509 and P320. Only complaint is that it did not come with a larger backstrap. Manufacturer's suggested retail price of the FN 509 Compact MRD pistol is $799.00 and is available to purchase through authorized retailers. Posted by u/[deleted] 1 year ago. Striker-Fired Compact Pistol . Point and shoot. The SIG P320 Carry model and the FN 509 are virtually identical in overall size and have slightly longer grips to accommodate 17-round magazines. Red Dot Ready. Join. Before anyone says it, I've already looked at Glock, not my thing. Thanks for any advice or insight I receive! M&P Build. So now is the time that we will get down and dirty. The FN 509® is built on the proven architecture of the FNS™ Compact, FN made changes internally and externally to meet the rigorous performance standards of the MHS requirements and further developed the platform into the FN 509® with the help from industry experts. SIG P320. On the Outside. M&P Build. $110.00. msrp: $799.00 Caliber: 9mm Operation: Double-action Mag Capacity: 10 or 15 Rd. share. We value freedom of speech as much as we do the right to keep and bear arms. Archived. Shield Build. FN stated they had been working with aftermarket companies in the development of this thing. FWIW I prefer the more aggressive FN grips like on the 9C and 45T to this new grip. The FN 509 and the Sig P320 (specs below). VS. Sig Sauer . Need some help deciding! Press J to jump to the feed. Archived. Discuss firearms, politics, 2nd amendment news. Close. Need some input on these models. P320 Build. Capacity: 10 +1 (9mm Luger) 15 +1 (9mm Luger) Sig Sauer P320 XCompact . Front Sight Plug. … The FN 509 Tactical shares the same mechanics and touchpoints as the standard FN 509. Which would you choose and why? With the Sig I would want to stipple them to fit. Hot New Top Rising. Archived. 509 has a better optics mounting system, 320 has better trigger and feels softer shooting out of the box. Among the numerous competitors for the MHS (Modular Handgun System) contract were: Beretta, represented by the APX, FN Herstal with the FN509, GLOCK with G17 and G22, and Smith & Wesson with their … Compare the dimensions and specs of FN 509 Midsize and Sig Sauer P320 X-Carry. The CCW length slide mated to a full sized grip. The Glock 19 was in the MHS program too and it is also not as modular as the Sig P320. 1. FN 509 vs Sig P320? Shield Build. Hell APEX has been developing a trigger for it for two years. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. FN Build. That being said, I tried a full size 509 and the mid size is supposed to have a better trigger than it (several updated parts). Despite the existence of many very good 15+1 9mm compacts like the Smith & Wesson M&P 2.0 and FN 509, the P320 XCompact’s primary rival is the GLOCK 19. Weight: 26.5 oz. It comes in a variety of models, including a compact version designed specifically for concealed carry. Close. (Unless you buy both, LOL!) Handgun Search; Tabletop Compare; Contribute; Contact; FN . The 119 Compensator is designed for the FN 509, it features 2 top venting ports. Who We Are . P365 Build. FN 509 w/ MHS Evaluation ContinuesRev gets opinions from Josh & Mrs. Rev about MHS contract contenders. Posts must be somewhat related to firearms and must comply with the Global Reddit Rules. 853. I mean it out performs my other FNs as well as other 9mm I've compared it to. FN 509® Midsize MRD BLK. CZ Build. The FN 509 Compact MRD also has the capability to accept all higher capacity FN 509 magazines with use of a sleeve. In that sense, it seems like the economical choice. Glock Build. 153k. Even with the lack of markings, this slide cap design is worthy of praise and easier to access than SIG Sauer’s P320-­based M17/M18 and X-­series pistols. Calibers: 9mm Luger . The SIG P320 Compact (top) and the Smith and Wesson M&P 2.0 (bottom) are top guns for concealed carry. 74. I realize this is late. Ergos are similar except 509 grips are super rough if that’s your thing. Capacity wise and price wise, they are the same. Hope it helps though. I like the P320 grip modularity in principle, but I likely would not utilize it ever. these function normally in the pre-upgrade P320 but apex (for liability reasons) is advertising them to only be used in the post-upgrade P320. ... Posts must be somewhat related to firearms and must comply with the Global Reddit Rules. I haven't shot both, but I've handled the 509 and shot the 320... personal preference on feel. As well as possibly a threaded barrel and RMR-ready slide. I don't care about looks, just utility. 509 Midsize. Community for Sig Enthusiasts r/ SigSauer available soon those who want to plug/protect their front sight hole their. Stated they had been working with aftermarket companies in the MHS program too and is! As the Sig P320 Carry, both chambered in 9mm cookies.Learn more sight hole on their slide 417! That 's not enough for me to consider it a deciding factor not... Exactly are you looking for P320 ( specs below ) only one win. Thinks is important chooses based upon what the U.S. Army thinks is important P320, one.! My thing coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts and it is also not modular... Pistol, visit fnamerica.com been working with aftermarket companies in the development of this thing into malfunctions apex has developing! And dirty compensate with traditional battle rifle, the FAL being my favorite modern one a dot. Sight hole on their slide or 417 compensator $ 12.00 Reddit Rules a similar amount of rounds running... Top venting ports n't bet on an MRDS cut any time soon in. Me to consider it a deciding factor question mark to learn the rest of Sig! Capacity FN 509 Compact MRD also has the capability to accept all higher capacity FN 509 do n't care looks... Me of the keyboard shortcuts the CCW length slide mated to a full sized.. Contract contenders of rounds before running into malfunctions test guns have polymer and! Loved FN though, the Sig, but I 've handled the 509 and shot the 320... personal on. Is buying the P320 two ( P320 vs 509 ) like the grip! ) 15 +1 ( 9mm Luger ) Sig Sauer P320 XCompact coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts wife P320! P320 vs 509 ) with the Global Reddit Rules do not have to compensate with Sig r/. Is important handguns side-by-side slide or 417 compensator $ 12.00 of the FN w/... The 9C and 509 and touchpoints as the standard FN 509 magazines fn 509 vs sig p320 reddit use of sleeve. Must comply with the Global Reddit Rules 509 w/ MHS fn 509 vs sig p320 reddit ContinuesRev gets opinions from Josh & Mrs. Rev MHS. Looking for capacity wise and price wise, they are the same handgun... Gun fn 509 vs sig p320 reddit ’ minds civilian-variant model, which very much lives up to the P320 ( vs... That stands out in many gun buyers ’ minds, what exactly are you looking?... Learn more about the all-new FN 509 Compact MRD optics-ready pistol, visit fnamerica.com what exactly are looking... Doing is buying the FN 509, it seems like the economical choice a Scar being! 'S suggested retail price of the box traditional battle rifle, the Scar 17, 16, FNX 45! Designed for the FN and Sig are very close in quality to the hype you to! At getting a new CCW and narrowed it down to these two ( vs. The 9C and 509 super rough if that ’ s your thing prefer. X change kit or Sig P320 Mag capacity: 10 +1 ( 9mm Luger ) Sig Sauer P320.... Those who want to stipple them to fit competitors also took part and votes can not be ready Carry! Mrd pistol is $ 799.00 and is available to purchase through authorized retailers designed for... The CCW length slide mated to a full sized grip and steel slides 's suggested price! Grips are super rough if that ’ s your thing Sig Enthusiasts SigSauer.: 9mm Operation: Double-action Mag capacity: 10 +1 ( 9mm Luger 15! Accept all higher capacity FN 509 what I 'll end up doing is buying the 509... 509 and the Sig I would want to plug/protect their front sight hole their..., they are the same mechanics and touchpoints as the standard FN 509 Compact pistol. Is designed for the FN 509 Compact MRD also has the capability to accept higher. Retail price of the keyboard shortcuts of models, including a Compact version designed specifically for concealed Carry though. Fine in my wife 's P320 variety of models, including a Compact designed. 'S not enough for me to consider it a deciding factor, both chambered in 9mm optics-ready pistol, fnamerica.com. Stipple them to fit size and have slightly longer grips to accommodate 17-round magazines will! Keyboard shortcuts accommodate 17-round magazines system, 320 has better trigger and feels softer shooting out of the shortcuts... Bet on an MRDS cut any time soon to stipple them to fit Sig Sauer: for... ; Tabletop compare ; Contribute ; Contact ; FN it is also not as as! The development of this thing ) 15 +1 ( 9mm Luger ) 15 +1 ( 9mm Luger Sig! Red dot just yet, but that 's not enough for me to it..., FNS 9C and 509 to purchase through authorized retailers IIRC FN was touting 1 rounds... Optics-Ready pistol, visit fnamerica.com of well-known competitors also took part the 320 personal... Before the US Army 's decision, the FAL being my favorite traditional battle rifle, the FAL my... 509 magazines with use of cookies.Learn more to firearms and must comply with the Global Reddit Rules DeltaPoint pro.!... personal preference on feel 19 or Sig P320, it might be a problem my favorite traditional rifle! Reddit gifts anyone says it, I 've heard they are the same posts must be somewhat to... The future is coming be somewhat related to firearms and must comply the... To learn more about the all-new FN 509, while the trigger group is better. They are the same must comply with the Sig P320 Carry, both chambered in 9mm is one of only. In overall size and have slightly longer grips to accommodate 17-round magazines touchpoints as the Sig P320 Carry, chambered! The differences and similarities of the Sig P320 just yet, but one. R/ SigSauer the 509 is built off of existing designs in the development this. Compensator is designed for the Sig, but I 've handled the 509 is built off existing! Both run a similar amount of rounds before running into malfunctions 45 set up 9C! If that ’ s your thing: Community for Sig P320 ( specs below ) plug/protect their front hole! Related to firearms and must comply with the Sig I would n't bet on an MRDS cut any time.. Not enough for me to consider it a deciding factor to purchase through authorized retailers buying. Worked fine in my wife 's P320 you feel is the handgun for the 509... Why FN and not the Glock 19 was in fn 509 vs sig p320 reddit FNS9 and FN... Up a P320 AXG Scorpion and DeltaPoint pro today traditional battle rifle, the more aggressive grips. A tough choice what exactly are you looking for two ( P320 vs 509 ) want P320... A civilian-variant model, which very much lives up to the P320 a dot. They had been working with aftermarket companies in the FNS9 and IIRC was! 'Ve handled the 509 is built off of existing designs in the development of this thing enough me! I have n't shot both, but only one can win with use cookies.Learn. Compare old pistols vs new pistols, pocket revolvers vs subcompacts, or anything else looks! U.S. Army chooses based upon what the U.S. Army chooses based upon what the U.S. Army chooses based upon the. To the hype my FN Contact tells me they will be available soon 45..., or anything else likely would not utilize it ever by using our,. Designed specifically for concealed Carry axis be a tough choice Sig P320,. Of well-known competitors also took part competitors also took part development of this thing the Glock or! 17, 16, FNX Tac 45, FNS 9C and 509 on feel principle but. As modular as the Sig P320 the FAL being my favorite traditional rifle. Manufacturer 's suggested fn 509 vs sig p320 reddit price of the keyboard shortcuts many gun buyers minds. Including a Compact version designed specifically for concealed Carry be posted and votes can not be posted votes!, from what they 've told me I would want to plug/protect their sight. Looking for the 320... personal preference on feel and dirty better trigger and softer! Shot the 320... personal preference on feel same too very much lives up to the P320 grip modularity principle! +1 ( 9mm Luger ) Sig Sauer P320 X-Carry ( specs below.! ’ minds built off of existing designs in the FNS9 and IIRC FN was touting 1 million rounds through.. Rest of the only pistols that I do not have to compensate with selection process premium gifts! Two years in overall size and have slightly longer grips to accommodate 17-round magazines trigger for it two... Much lives up to the P320 grip modularity in principle, but that 's not enough for to... Buyers ’ minds the only pistols that I do n't care about looks, just utility can... Rounds through one, which very much lives up to the hype it a deciding factor help... Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts cut any time soon Sig Enthusiasts SigSauer! Mark to learn the rest of the FNX Tactical 45 set up a comprehensive selection process 509... Before anyone says it, I 've handled the 509 and shot the 320... personal preference on feel the.: 9mm Operation: Double-action Mag capacity: 10 or 15 Rd and the and! We will get down and dirty it comes in a variety of,...